Mexican filmmaker Ernesto Contreras’s fourth feature film with a script by his brother (Carlos Contreras) is a magical mythical tale about the search for a language that is on the brink of extinction, because the last two remaining elderly speakers are bitter enemies who haven’t exchanged a word for the past 50 years.
Martin (Fernando Álvarez Rebeil ) is a young linguist expert who has traveled to a remote part of Mexico in the hope of recording some conversations with these last two people known to be fluent in Zikril. There was a 3rd person but she dies practically as soon as Martin arrives in the tiny hamlet in the jungle, so he is left with no alternative than trying to get Don Isauro (José Manuel Poncelis) and Don Evaristo (Eligio Meléndez)to agree to talk to each other.
Isauro never married but widowed Evaristo lives with his granddaughter Lluvia (Fátima Molina) who is the one who eventually shares with Martin how the two men who had been blood brothers had fallen out over a girl when they were teenagers. The twist was the fact that Evaristo had only married her to suppress his true sexuality and stop her from sharing what she had witnessed on the beach one hot summers day.
It takes time, and the bribe of a new television, to get the two men to now agree to have a conversation, and to everyone’s relief it is a great success and they actually start to renew their friendship. However this new turn of events doesn’t last long as though both men still have this deep bond for each other, whilst Isuaro remembers it fondly, Evaristo is still very ashamed and violently turns on his old friend yet once again.
This is all set against the story of trying not just trying to save this lost language, but be a witness to an ancient fading culture that is steeped in mysticism such as the mammoth cave in the jungle where the spirits take all the Zikril people’s bodies when they die. It’s a society that sees things differently than most others, but obviously not when it comes to sexuality.
It’s an intriguing movie with the back story told in flashbacks, and one that makes a great use of the rather stunning dramatic vistas. It unfolds at a slow gentle pace and even the side plot of Martin hooking up with Lluvia, doesn’t ease the sadness of the way these two men led such unhappy lives simply because they were never allowed to their true selves.
“I Dream In Another Language” will be shown at Outwatch – Wine Country’s LGBTQI Film Festival Sunday, November 5 at 2:45 p.m. at Third Street Cinema in Santa Rosa. For more information, go to: www.outwatchfilmfest.org. All profits from the film festival will be donated to Wildfire Relief Funds for LGBTQI folks.
When 14 year old Ulysses’s (Luka Kain) father suddenly dies, his mother (Margot Bingham) has to take on a second job to make ends meet. She somewhat reluctantly accepts an offer from Ulysses’ ultra-conservative Aunt Rose (Regina Taylor) to come to take care of him and his younger sibling after work until she gets home. The teenager is in the throws of discovering his sexuality and identity, and when Rose finds out he has been secretly trying on his mother’s shoes she doesn’t let up on him for one single moment.
On a whim he takes himself off on the subway to the West Village and after wandering around aimlessly for hours stumbles on a small group of friends who befriend him and persuade him to join them at Church. This is not for any religious service but is for the weekly LGBT drop-in center in the crypt where they get a meal and support.
As each of his new young friends share their (mostly unhappy) stories of how they got to this stage of their lives, their sense of optimism and empowerment starts to gradually effect Ulysses, and he starts making regular trips to the Church every Saturday night.
He is still being bullied at school and Aunt Rose keeps up her meanness, but now encouraged by his very first group of friends to consider entering an upcoming Vogueing competition, the young teenager happily buys himself a rather wicked pair of studded stiletto shoes. However when Aunt Rose is spying in his bedroom, and discovers them, an almighty row breaks out ending up with Rose throwing him out.
He immediately flees to the Church, but as this is midweek there is no sign of anyone and so left to his own devices he ends up at a homeless shelter where his shirt gets taken, and next day on the streets he gets picked up and loses his virginity.
This cute and compelling coming-of-age tale which does have a realistic and conclusive ending is by no means a new story, but its take on it is refreshing and innovative. It is aided by the fact that openly gay newbie filmmaker Damon Cardasis turned this into a hybrid musical with catchy original songs accompanied by some impressive choreography.
The central performance from its young star is totally stunning with his wonderful sense of innocence and abandonment, and it is what really makes this drama feel so authentic and so extremely watchable.
“Saturday” Church” will be shown at Outwatch – Wine Country’s LGBT Film Festival, Saturday November a at 12:30 p.m. at Third Street Cinema in Santa Rosa. For more info, go to: www.outwatchfilmfest.org.
If David France’s Oscar nominated ‘How To Survive a Plague‘ is recognized as the seminal movie on AIDS in the US, then Robin Campillo’s stunning new masterpiece BPM (Beats Per Minute) is undoubtably Europe’s candidate for the title. His sprawling and somewhat harrowing tale that centers on the ACT UP group in Paris is based on his own experiences as an activist in the 1990’s, but he adds a fictional love story that makes his account of the pandemic in France that much more personal and highly emotional.
The story starts at the Group’s volatile weekly meetings (WM) where the leaders insist on a rigid procedure so that they can get through their usually packed agenda. Everyone participating is fueled by anger and frustration, and they are passionate about getting the Authorities and Pharmaceutical Companies to actually take stop stalling and take some action as the current early regime of drugs are proving useless at keeping the Virus from being fata
As figures are released showing that the rate of new people being diagnosed as HIV+ are higher in France than any other European countries at that time, and many of the Paris collective see their T Cell counts drop down to to dangerous low levels quickly, the need to take action takes on a greater urgency.
At the WM’s there are plenty of heated discussions on what form of guerrilla actions they should take to not just get their case across, but to also force the hand of both Mitterand’s inactive Government and the reluctant Drug Companies. The cast of characters include Thibault (Antoine Reinartz) their articulate leader who along with Sophie (Adèle Haenel) one of the organizers, prefers a more diplomatic approach to how they should carry out the group’s avowed aims. This however does nor sit well with more militant members such as Sean (Nahuel Pérez Biscayart) who want to adopt more aggressive and confrontational tactics which they firmly believe is the only way to make the Authorities take them seriously.
Sean’s passionate determination attracts the attention of Nathan (Arnaud Valois) one of the group’s newest members, and one of the rare ones who is HIV negative. Whilst the first half of Campillo’s drama focuses on the trials and tribulations of the ACT UP group and their activities, the latter part centers on the romantic relationship of the two men as they first become lovers, and then eventually as Nathan takes on the role of carer as Sean ‘s health rapidly deteriorates.
Campillo so perfectly captures the bewilderment of a community that struggles hard just to stay alive and abreast of every single development such as new reactions to the existing regime of AIDS drugs which were proving so ineffective. This was the era immediately before the advent of the arrival of protease inhibitors which would finally change the playing field for nearly everyone who had been diagnosed HIV+. It is however the sheer authenticity of his script that makes this such a chilling and painfully disturbing film to watch, and by including the story of Nathan and Sean’s brief but intense relationship, makes it also devastatingly heartbreaking .
The cast most of whom were born after this period are pitch perfect in their portrayal of the indignant dying youth, particular the two lead actors. Valois as the slightly mysterious and compassionate Nathan was a real revelation, even more so when you discover that he had given up on acting a few years ago to focus on being a masseur. 30 year old Argentinian actor Pérez Biscayart playing Sean may not have looked his age, but he had this piercing intensity that made his superb performance so utterly compelling.
Campillo’s shockingly brilliant movie deservedly swooped up 4 major awards when it premiered at the Cannes Film Festival earlier this year. However the accolade that it would be honored for, and which in many eyes is even more important, is the fact that Campillo gives us a telling of this crucial part of our history actually through queer eyes, something that Hollywood would never dare to do.
A rather compelling Tony Award Winner Lena Hall in her first starring role in a movie, makes this rather cute musical a much more entertaining experience than one may have otherwise expected from what is a somewhat very predictable drama. Hall plays Becks an aspiring musician who packs up her life in New York to drive to L.A. to join the love of her life. She makes better time on the journey than she expects, and arriving a day early surprises her girlfriend who is the midst of entertaining a naked girl in her room.
With her tail between her legs Becks angrily drives off to the middle of suburbia somewhere and back to her childhood home where her ultra-religious widowed mother (played by the wonderful Christine Lahti) still lives. After an obligatory few weeks of being a self-pitying couch potato, Becks is shamed into getting out in the world again by her mother. ‘The world’ in this instance being a rather dingy bar called Perfectos run by Dave (Dan Fogler) an old schoolhood chum of hers, and the only man she has ever balled.
As Becks is broke Dave suggest that she brings her guitar and play for tips at the weekend when the number of his patrons sometimes goes into double figures. One of the people in the crowd is Elyse (Mena Suvari) who Becks bumps into a few days later when she is window shopping at Elyse’s Vintage Clothing Store. She is married to another of Beck’s ex schoolmates, but not one she liked, and the couple live in a great big rather sterile mansion where Elyse is bored out of her mind.
The two women get closer when a very curious Elyse takes private guitar lessons, and it is clear to everyone where this will lead too. And it does. It is inevitable in this small town where everyone knows everybody’s business that this clandestine affair cannot last. One of the funnier scenes in the movie is when Beck’s mother catches her daughter wearing a ‘strap on’ and penetrating a rather naive Elyse in broad daylight.
Evidently the movie is very loosely inspired on incidents in the life of Alyssa Robbins, a singer-songwriter who with composer Steve Salett wrote most of the very fresh-sounding touching songs that Hall got to sing.
The movie is the feature directing debut of Elizabeth Rohrbaugh and Daniel Powell from a script that they co-wrote with Rebecca Drysdale and thanks to its cast, this entertaining wee drama, turned out far better than poor Becks love life itself.
For his first feature film writer/director Mike Roma reunites with actor Patrick Reilly who starred in his successful TV series Danny the Manny about a cute gay out-of-work actor in Hollywood having to become a nanny to a surly 6 year old simply to survive. This time round Reilly plays Danny a rather obnoxious, aspiring but unemployed gay screenwriter, and even though his character is beyond annoying, Reilly the actor puts in such a winning performance that we cannot help but like him.
The story is a fresh take on the whole mother/son dynamic in what appears to be an unhealthy relationship with Joan (Kathryn Erbe) a single-parent indulging her spoilt teenage son to the point of letting him even share her bed. We should hasten to add that this is no oedipus complex just the case of a lazy youth who considers this part of the home comforts he wants to make life in New Jersey bearable whilst he waits to return to L.A. where he just graduated from college.
However the whole arrangement has to drastically alter when Joan is egged on by her best friend Lisa (the wonderful Kathy Najimy) to jump back into the dating pool again by creating an online profile. Danny, with more than a hint of jealously, is dismissive of his mother’s efforts particularly as he never manages to have any success on gay hook-up sites. He is then more than annoyed when she has possibly hit the jackpot on her very first attempt when she meets Chester (James Le Gros).
Now forced to move back into his own bedroom and take on a part time menial job at the Library, Danny seeks refuge with Kris (Michael Rosen) one of his old school pals who has a steady supply of pot to smoke. As the two of them start to bond more, Danny suggests they take a road trip to L.A. together as he is determined to get back there somehow. Kris is more than keen to go along with this, but then when Danny misreads all the friendliness and plants a kiss on the horrified straight-boy’s lips, this immediately blows all his chances of both the trip and his continued friendship.
He is not the only one who has to deal with some of the harsher elements of the real world as Lisa has just discovered that her husband of 30 years has been continually unfaithful and she throws him out of the house. Meanwhile Joan who had been the only one who seemed to have no future, is now radiant in her new found happiness with a boyfriend who looks like he is going to be around for a long time.
Roma however who had evidently used elements from his own life for the story does however ensure that before it all plays out Danny does in fact wake up and smell the roses giving this very entertaining and touching comedy the happy ending that it so deserved.
Probably the funny part of the piece is the way Roma portrays how the generations differ when it comes to ‘dating’ as Joan is all about billing and cooing on the phone for hours, whereas Danny is trying to swipe right on the endless array of dick pics that he is sorting through to find a ‘suitor’ online.
God’s Own Country a breakout hit at both Sundance and Berlinale Festivals (where it was nominated for a Teddy for Best Queer Feature) is a remarkable debut from openly gay Brit writer/director Frances Lee, and unquestionably one of best queer love stories for a very long time. Set in the wilds of Yorkshire (hence the title) with two young sheep farmers, the comparison with Brokeback Mountain is inevitable, but frankly Lee’s film offers entirely different perspectives on the unexpected relationship between these two rough country men, and most of all, it offers hope.
24 year old Johnny (Josh O’Connor) is a man of few words. Forced to take over the running of his family’s farm single-handedly since his rather gruff father (Ian Hart) became ill, and with his mother having walked out years ago, the only other person at home was his grandmother (Gemma Jones) who acted as the housekeeper. The farm nestled in the bleak Yorkshire moors offering Johnny little respite from all the pressures of physically managing all the endless daily chores in the most inhospitable of weathers. Added to the fact that his father was constantly complaining anytime he deviated from doing things the way that he wanted them done and told that his ideas were ‘daft’.
Each night he escaped to Bradford the nearest town and just binge drank until he could hardly stand, and would end up throwing up when he barely made it home. \Very occasionally like when he went to the Cattle Market, he would encounter a young lad who he would have a wordless sexual encounter in the back of his van, and then be totally horrified when the lad would try and kiss him afterwards.
When lambing season came around and he needed some manual help to cope, his father hired a migrant Romanian worker for the week. Johnny took an instant dislike to to the handsome swarthy Gheorghe (Alec Secareanu) who he derogatory called ‘Gypsy’ and the two men barely communicated with each other, until that is they were forced to camp out together for a new nights to be closer to the flock. They were still acting rather sullenly towards each other, but somehow by the second night the two of them impulsively jumped on each other and started making.
Johnny who knew no better wanted his usual quick sexual release, but the older man took control and forced him into a making it all a much more emotional act of making love. The transformation the next day was remarkable because in that one brief encounter Gheorghe had shown him more affection than anyone else had done in his life time.
Developing any sort of relationship beyond this was pretty impossible with the need to keep it totally secret, but actually even when his grandmother came across a used condom in his bedroom and worked out what was going on, she kept her discovery to herself. Then with the father suffering another stroke and being totally incapacitated, Johnny seized on the opportunity to ask Gheorghe to stay on longer to help out on the farm . Even though the Romanian was more than happy to do so, it was inevitable that as Johnny had repressed his feelings for so long and had never ever been able to either verbalize or even accept them, then it wouldn’t be easy. It was fairly obvious that inexperienced as he was he would that he would make some errors of judgement that would jeopardize their potential relationship.
Lee’s excellent script is based partly on his own experiences growing up in a very similar farm in that same neck of the woods, and although he claims that the work is not autobiographical, it does at least reference his own difficult in forming any sort of loving relationship in a rural area like this. A lot of the credit for the movie’s success is due to the casting decisions he made for O’Connor and Secareanu had this intense chemistry that made the whole piece sing. The young British actor has been making a name for himself playing bit parts in big production movies (like Florence Foster Jenkins) but his understated performance as the awkward gangly Johnny proved he could play the lead too. He was a sheer joy to watch. The Romanian in his first English speaking playing the sultry and sensitive Geheorge became the man that most of us would happily fall in love with behind the sheep pen.
Kudos to for the actors who really had to get down and dirty with the animals themselves. How Lee persuaded to get them to be up close and way too personal with them, is beyond us. It certainly lent a real authenticity to the piece, but not one we would want to see too much off.
On a brighter note, there was a very casual naturalness to the nudity which was unusually explicit for a Brit movie, and the scenes of intimacy which developed from being rushed to being instinctive and tender and seemingly totally un-choreographed, making them so very sizzling hot.
Lee’s drama treads a refreshing path and with this enchanting romance shot in the stark beauty of the Yorkshire countryside, it’s a film that will resound so very well within the LGBT community that it is sure to become a new favorite cult gay classic.
Transit Havana is an intriguing documentary from Dutch filmmaker Daniel Abma that is essentially a commentary on what it is like to be transgender in socialist Cuba especially now that is going through a state of flux since the Regime is lightening up after the US started making friendly overtures at last. Abma chooses to follow a trans man and two trans woman about their daily lives as they wait to see in the official Committee has chosen them to have gender realignment surgery. The good news for them is that the whole procedure is free, but the sad news is that only 5 such operations can be done every year when for one week only two Dutch surgeons volunteer their services.
Juani, is in his 60’s and he who refers to himself as Cuba’s first official transsexual, having started out on his journey in the 1970’s. He has already fully transitioned and has had reconstructive surgery, but is now hoping for an additional procedure to make his male anatomy function better during sexual encounters.
Malú is one tough cookie who has been living as a female since she was a teenager. She is fierce and funny and devotes a great deal of her time to being a transgender rights activist, and is in fact a natural-born leader for her community. She unabashedly admits to have being a sex-worker, and there is a scene of her visiting her boyfriend of seven years who is now in jail for a reason that is never actually revealed. Malú is convinced that the fact that she is so outspoken is the reason why she still has not been selected for the surgery that she so desperately wants.
The third one is Odette who is the only one of the group who is struggling with acceptance from her family. She is a former Army tank specialist who now makes a very basic living out of doing menial jobs on a very small farm where her boss says that he only employed because he believed it was God’s will. Odette’s own religious beliefs still make it difficult for her to come to terms with being trans, and also accepting that her own Pastor is trying to convince her that surgery would be wrong in the eyes of God.
Getting equally as much time in the documentary is the charismatic daughter of the Cuban Leader Raúl Castro. Mariela is the head of Cuban National Center for Sex Education and the country’s most prominent LGBT activist amongst the political elite. She has unquestionably been the major force behind all the progress made in improving the community’s rights, and without her certain things like this gender-realignment surgery would never have happened. However she does never stop spouting the official Party line on how wonderful Socialism is, which is still tough for us to comprehend when everyone else in this documentary is literally struggling to survive and put enough food on their tables.
Abma’s subjects all made for such compelling viewing, so much so that it we share their pain when they discover that they have not been chosen for surgery again this year. In fact if there was one criticism of this otherwise quite perfect documentary it is that we never get even so much as a hint of how the Committee base their decisions on who gets selected and who gets rejected.
Married lesbian couple Cari Searcy and Kim McKeand who live with their son in Mobil, say that their friends always ask “Why Alabama? You must be crazy.” It is the exact same question that any LGBTQ person will probably also ask at the beginning of this new compelling documentary that tells the story of their lives, and that of another lesbian couple who have to deal with so much more intransigence and unabashed homophobia in this the most conservative State in the US. However what we initially perceive will be a tale of almost sheer helplessness, turns out in the end as story of how hope, love and sheer determination can still make Alabama the right place for these particular families to call home.
Cari and Kim’s problems started with the birth of their son who was born with a hole in his heart, and Kim was denied any involvement in his treatment as a co-parent. Using the fact that her California marriage to Ceri was not recognized by Alabama, the Judge denied her the right to be able to adopt him too. This starts almost a whole decade long through the Court system, which although gave them some victories along the way, they still had to deal with their own State’s judiciary and officialdom who refused to comply with the rulings.
When Kinley separated from the birth father of her child, he easily won full custody of their son, once his lawyer told the Court that Kinley was a lesbian. She and her wife Autumn then have to deal with several legal rebuttals to right the situation, and even when the boy has to be hospitalized because his stepmom had whipped him so hard, the Judge still actually treated Kinley in court as if being a lesbian was far worse than an actual child beater. It took her almost two years of several aborted Court appearances for Kinley to win the case and be able to keep her son, but as the final credits roll, there is a cautionary note that the father is still trying to challenge the decision.
These two stories are sandwiched between the tale of Patricia Todd a disarmingly charming lesbian who gets elected as the first openly gay state representative in Alabama, and the lone legislative voice of its LGBTQ community. Todd, ever a pragmatist, works hard to personally win over as many of the ultra-conservatives of the House in her attempt to stop the flow of potential anti-LGBTQ legislation becoming law in her State, and bristles when her colleagues tell her ‘not to take it personally’ as they seek to reduce our rights.
Like the others in this documentary, Todd is inspirational, although in her case it came at a personal cost when she chose her political career over her marriage. It may not be enough to want anyone to pack up their bags and move to this part of the Deep South at any time …….. especially whilst Judge Roy Moore is still hovering around ….. but it is now very clear why these woman are still happy to call Alabama home.
Emmy Award-winning filmmaker Jeffrey Schwarz has added another subject to his series of documentaries on iconic LGBT figures which so far have included Wrangler: Anatomy of an Icon, Tab Hunter Confidential, I Am Divine, and Vito. This time his subject Allan Carr may be not quite so well known to the general public, but his successful career as an infamous larger-than-life flamboyant Hollywood Producer and Agent make him a natural fit for one of Schwarz’s excellent and very compelling profiles.
Carr was born Allan Solomon in 1937, the only son of a wealthy Jewish family in Chicago and his parents spoilt him rotten, and indulged his every whim. From an early age he was fascinated to the point of being obsessed with everything to do with show business, especially with stars. One of his first ventures as a young man was that he opened Chicago’s Civic Theater and financed The World of Carl Sandburg starring Bette Davis who was touring with her then husband Gary Merrill.
Carr moved to L.A. in 1966 and changed his name and opened up his own talent agency Allan Carr Enterprises, and quickly demonstrated that he was not just a first-class salesman, but that he had a lot of chutzpah too as he was soon managing major stars such Tony Curtis, Peter Sellers, Rosalind Russell, Dyan Cannon, Melina Mercouri, and Marlo Thomas.
Carr was first and foremost a showman, and as well as managing his Clients, he started to achieve a reputation for mounting extraordinary lavish promotional parties like the one the Australian impresario Robert Stigwood employed him to do for the rock musical movie Tommy, and then after that for the premiere of Saturday Night Fever. These events propelled Stigwood into making Carr the producer of the movie Grease who’s phenomenally world-wide success became the high-point of Carr’s roller-coast career.
Without doubt Carr’s best talent was in self-promotion and in publicizing his own involvement in his projects which were always at the expense of others who got totally overlooked, as in the case Grease’s director Randal Kleiser who was all but forgotten. Carr took the full credit for everything because he always made it about himself, so when he faced failure as with the campy musical he followed Grease with Can’t Stop The Music which totally bombed at the box office and was savaged by the critics, he took it all very personally.
Schwarz makes no attempt at hiding the very obvious fact that Carr had his own personal demons. He was a compulsive overeater who in the end took to wearing nothing but voluminous kaftans to hide his enormous figure, and as a gay man he surrounded himself with scantily clad pretty boys, yet never had his first sexual experience until he was in his 30’s. When it came to sex it seems that he was more of a voyeur than a player and at his celebrated pool parties in his lavish and glamorous mansion he would entertain ‘A’ list movie stars and Hollywood royalty alongside with some of the gay demimonde. When the stars left, then the party would quickly become nothing less than an orgy to satisfy Carr’s predilection for watching his stable of boys make out together, and occasionally even getting involved.
Carr always coveted professional respectability and acceptance which he finally got when in 1983 he produced La Cage Aux Follies the first stage musical on Broadway to tackle a gay theme head on. It was a mega success running for five years and 1,761 performances, and winning an impressive six Tonys, including a “Best Musical” win for Carr.
This success however was followed by a spectacular failure in 1989 when Carr landed his dream job of producing the 61st Annual Academy Awards. He was hired to create a show based on his promise that he would turn it around from the dry, dull show it had been in previous years, but the end result was panned by both the critics and the members of the Academy who publicly denounced Carr. Being censored by the Hollywood elite who he considered were his peers and friends was the worse thing ever for the overly sensitive Carr who never ever managed to salvage his reputation in the movie community after that.
It is hard not to warm to the opportunistic Carr who mixed his extraordinary flair with a great deal of charm and this very scary aspect of knowing that he was so out of his depth so very much of his time, a fact that never seem to daunt him in the very least. Carr’s life may be a mystery to many of us which in itself is a great pity but at least Schwarz’s affectionate profile will quite rightly change all that. Going into the movie you may struggle recalling who he was, but after 9o minutes you have had a glimpse at the star-studded rather glamorous life that would sadly seem so out of place in the more overly micro-managed of today.
The Fabulous Allan Carr is not only an essential piece of our community’s history that should be seen by everyone, it is also a rather fabulous movie too.
The Fabulous Allan Carr
Emmy Award-winning filmmaker Jeffrey Schwarz has added another subject to his series of documentaries on iconic LGBT figures which so far have included Wrangler: Anatomy of an Icon, Tab Hunter Confidential, I Am Divine, and Vito. This time his subject Allan Carr may be not quite so well known to the general public, but his successful career as an infamous larger-than-life flamboyant Hollywood Producer and Agent make him a natural fit for one of Schwarz’s excellent and very compelling profiles.
Carr was born Allan Solomon in 1937, the only son of a wealthy Jewish family in Chicago and his parents spoilt him rotten, and indulged his every whim. From an early age he was fascinated to the point of being obsessed with everything to do with show business, especially with stars. One of his first ventures as a young man was that he opened Chicago’s Civic Theater and financed The World of Carl Sandburg starring Bette Davis who was touring with her then husband Gary Merrill.
Carr moved to L.A. in 1966 and changed his name and opened up his own talent agency Allan Carr Enterprises, and quickly demonstrated that he was not just a first-class salesman, but that he had a lot of chutzpah too as he was soon managing major stars such Tony Curtis, Peter Sellers, Rosalind Russell, Dyan Cannon, Melina Mercouri, and Marlo Thomas.
Carr was first and foremost a showman, and as well as managing his Clients, he started to achieve a reputation for mounting extraordinary lavish promotional parties like the one the Australian impresario Robert Stigwood employed him to do for the rock musical movie Tommy, and then after that for the premiere of Saturday Night Fever. These events propelled Stigwood into making Carr the producer of the movie Grease who’s phenomenally world-wide success became the high-point of Carr’s roller-coast career.
Without doubt Carr’s best talent was in self-promotion and in publicizing his own involvement in his projects which were always at the expense of others who got totally overlooked, as in the case Grease’s director Randal Kleiser who was all but forgotten. Carr took the full credit for everything because he always made it about himself, so when he faced failure as with the campy musical he followed Grease with Can’t Stop The Music which totally bombed at the box office and was savaged by the critics, he took it all very personally.
Schwarz makes no attempt at hiding the very obvious fact that Carr had his own personal demons. He was a compulsive overeater who in the end took to wearing nothing but voluminous kaftans to hide his enormous figure, and as a gay man he surrounded himself with scantily clad pretty boys, yet never had his first sexual experience until he was in his 30’s. When it came to sex it seems that he was more of a voyeur than a player and at his celebrated pool parties in his lavish and glamorous mansion he would entertain ‘A’ list movie stars and Hollywood royalty alongside with some of the gay demimonde. When the stars left, then the party would quickly become nothing less than an orgy to satisfy Carr’s predilection for watching his stable of boys make out together, and occasionally even getting involved.
Carr always coveted professional respectability and acceptance which he finally got when in 1983 he produced La Cage Aux Follies the first stage musical on Broadway to tackle a gay theme head on. It was a mega success running for five years and 1,761 performances, and winning an impressive six Tonys, including a “Best Musical” win for Carr.
This success however was followed by a spectacular failure in 1989 when Carr landed his dream job of producing the 61st Annual Academy Awards. He was hired to create a show based on his promise that he would turn it around from the dry, dull show it had been in previous years, but the end result was panned by both the critics and the members of the Academy who publicly denounced Carr. Being censored by the Hollywood elite who he considered were his peers and friends was the worse thing ever for the overly sensitive Carr who never ever managed to salvage his reputation in the movie community after that.
It is hard not to warm to the opportunistic Carr who mixed his extraordinary flair with a great deal of charm and this very scary aspect of knowing that he was so out of his depth so very much of his time, a fact that never seem to daunt him in the very least. Carr’s life may be a mystery to many of us which in itself is a great pity but at least Schwarz’s affectionate profile will quite rightly change all that. Going into the movie you may struggle recalling who he was, but after 9o minutes you have had a glimpse at the star-studded rather glamorous life that would sadly seem so out of place in the more overly micro-managed of today.
The Fabulous Allan Carr is not only an essential piece of our community’s history that should be seen by everyone, it is also a rather fabulous movie too.
In this documentary that tells the story of the leading Argentinian LGBT activist Carlos Jáuregui, someone comments at one point ‘it’s important for our community to know where we have come from’ to which we would add, it is equally vital that we know who propelled us along the way too. Every LGBT community has a hero, often unsung and unknown to people outside of their reach, and this movie tells the story of one in particular who was the outspoken driving force for equality in Buenos Aires.
When Carlos Jáuregui finished his University degree in the late 1970’s he then went on to graduate school in Paris, followed by a couple of years in N.Y. which opened his eyes to how other countries had progressed on gay rights so much more than the Argentina that he returned too in 1982. That was however about to very slowly changed and after the Military Dictatorship fell and was replaced by an openly elected President, Carlos founded the country’s very first LGBT organization Argentina Homosexual Community (CHA) and became its first leader.
What he wanted for the fledging community was visibility and so he and his lover at the time became the first openly gay couple to be featured in a major magazine spread which was extremely controversial at the time. This also cost him his job as a University Professor, but renewed his ambition to raise the stakes even higher.
By this time his brother Roberto who was also gay had moved to Buenos Aires and as he loved performing wanted just fame and glory and not activism like his brother. However when they both were diagnosed with HIV, Roberto went public with the news ….. again a first for the community … and became a AIDS activist. Oddly enough Carlos kept his own diagnosis private, initially to protect Pablo his lover, who not only had the virus but was beginning to decline, but he still never revealed his status even after Pablo died.
Like so many other gay partners, the moment that Pablo died after Carlos had nursed him for ages, his late partner’s family turned up at the apartment and literally threw Carlos and his belongings out on to the street.
In 1992 Carlos led Argentina’s very first Gay Pride March, which although it was sparsely attended and most of the marchers wore face masks for fear of being recognized and losing their jobs, it was deemed a major success. In 1994 when the Catholic Cardinal made an outrageous public statement saying amongst other things that the LGBT community should be banished to their own country, it was Carlos who instigated legal proceedings against him.
However what seems to be Carlos’s biggest legacy is the fact that he insisted that to survive and prosper the LGBT community should really totally unite. The movement he claimed had four ‘legs’ : gays, lesbians, transexuals and transvestites , and if any one of the ‘legs’ were missing the ‘table’ would fall down. It set him aside as one of few gay male leaders anywhere that insisted that we should all be totally inclusive.
When the country’s National Constitution was changed in 1994, it gave Buenos Aires the right to write its own constitution. So two years later Carlos drafted what would be known as Article 11 of the Statute of the Autonomous City of Buenos Aires that proposed that you co no longer legally discriminate against people on the grounds of their sexual orientation or gender identity. However as soon as he submitted it Carlos started getting very ill and the clock started ticking for both the passing of the Law and his own life.
His very last public appearance was in that year’s Gay Pride March, but by now there were newer and younger voices prepared to take over his mantle.
After he died all of his colleagues from the political group GAY DC sat in the public gallery of City Hall as the Law was debated. Each of them had a photo of Carlos pinned to their chest, and Article 11 passed unanimously paving the way for more important laws in the future that would cover issues such as civil unions.
There was one final march where Carlos was still the figurehead when his coffin was paraded through the streets because people wanted to say goodby to him publicly and with dignity exactly like he had taught them to be about their own lives.
Whether his story will really resound with audiences outside of Argentina is a moot point, but as a global LGBT community it is important that we document our history of all the courageous men and women who devoted their own lives to improving the quality of ours that would follow. Technically writer/director Lucas Santa Ana (Bromance) had to rely heavily on some patchy archival footage and a collection of personal photographs of varying qualities, but despite these drawbacks Carlos’s story shines through so bright and was so very worthwhile knowing.